လူထုစိန္၀င္း
အစိုးရမဟုတ္တဲ့ အဖြဲ႔အစည္းလုိ႔ေခၚၾကတဲ့ “အင္ဂ်ီအို” ေတြ “အိုင္အင္ ဂ်ီအို” ေတြနဲ႔ ကုလသမဂၢအဖြဲ႔အစည္းလို႔ဆုိတဲ့ အဖြဲ႔ေတြအေၾကာင္း မ ၾကာခဏဆိုသလို ေရးခဲ့ပါတယ္။ အခုတေလာေတာ့ ခပ္စိပ္စိပ္ကေလး ကို ေရးျဖစ္ပါတယ္။ အင္တာဗ်ဴးေတြလည္း ေျဖခဲ့ေျပာခဲ့ပါတယ္။ အ ေၾကာင္းမသိသူတခ်ဳိ႕က ဘာေၾကာင့္ ဒါေလာက္မ်က္ မုန္းက်ဳိးေနတာ လဲလို႔ ေမးၾကပါတယ္။ “ျမန္မာေတြ ေမ်ာက္ျဖစ္ကုန္မွာစိုးလို႔” လုိ႔ပဲ လုိ တိုရွင္းေျဖေလ့ရွိပါတယ္။
အတုျမင္ အတတ္သင္မွာစိုး
ဟုတ္ပါတယ္ခင္ဗ်။ ေမ်ာက္ျပဆန္ေတာင္းသူေတြေၾကာင့္ က်ေနာ္တုိ႔ လူမ်ဳိး မသိမသာနဲ႔ ေမ်ာက္ျဖစ္ေနၾကတာေတာ့ အေတာ္ေလးၾကာေန ပါၿပီ။ ဒါေပမယ့္ ဘာမွမေျပာခဲ့ပါဘူး။ အခုေတာ့ က်ေနာ္တုိ႔ ျမန္မာလူမ်ဳိးေတြ ကိုယ္တုိင္က ကိုယ့္လူမ်ဳိးကို ေမ်ာက္အျဖစ္လက္ညိႇဳးထုိးျပၿပီး ေမ်ာက္ျပဆန္ေတာင္းသူ ျဖစ္လာၾကတာမ်ဳိးေတြ တေန႔တျခား မ်ားသထက္ မ်ားလာေနတာေၾကာင့္ ခပ္စိပ္စိပ္ေလး ေျပာေနေရးေနရတာျဖစ္တယ္။ ေစတနာရွင္းသန္႔တဲ့ လူငယ္ေလးေတြ “အတုျမင္ အတတ္သင္” ျဖစ္ကုန္ၾကမွာစိုးလုိ႔ပါ။ တႏွစ္ကို တႀကိမ္ေလာက္၊ ႏွစ္ႀကိမ္ေလာက္ သတိေပး ေရး သားေနရင္းကေတာင္ တန္႔သြားမယ့္အစား ပိုပိုၿပီး က်ယ္ျပန္႔လာတာေၾကာင့္ ခုလုိ ခပ္စိပ္စိပ္ ေျပာရေရးရတာ ျဖစ္တယ္။
ဘယ္သူ႔မွ အားမကိုးနဲ႔
ဘယ္ထိ အေျခအေနဆုိးတယ္ဆုိတာ ေျပာျပပါမယ္။ မွတ္မွတ္ရရေျပာရရင္ ဒီလုိအဖြဲ႔အစည္းေတြ အေၾကာင္းစ ၿပီး ေဝဖန္ေရးသားခဲ့တာ ပထမအႀကိမ္က ကုလသမဂၢနဲ႔ပတ္သက္တာျဖစ္ၿပီး ေနာက္တႀကိမ္ကေတာ့ အိုင္အင္ ဂ်ီအိုတခုနဲ႔ ပတ္သက္တာျဖစ္တယ္။ လြန္ခဲ့တဲ့ ေလးငါးႏွစ္ေလာက္က “ဂမ္ဘာရီ” ဆုိတဲ့ ပုဂိၢဳလ္ႀကီး ျမန္မာ့ႏုိင္ ငံေရးကိစၥ ၾကား၀င္ေျဖရွင္းဖုိ႔ ျမန္မာႏိုင္ငံကို လာမယ္ဆုိတုန္းက ျပည္တြင္းျပည္ပ ႏိုင္ငံေရးေလ့လာသူေတြနဲ႔ ႏိုင္ငံေရးဂု႐ုေတြ၊ ႏိုင္ငံေရးပါတီႀကီးေတြက ဂမ္ဘာရီလာမွာကိုပဲ သိၾကားမင္းႀကီး ဆင္းလာသလုိ အူျမဴးေနၾက တာေတြကို ျမင္ေတြ႔ေနရတဲ့အတြက္ ျမန္မာ့ကိစၥကို ျမန္မာေတြ ကိုယ္တုိင္ရွင္းမွရမယ္။ ကုလသမဂၢလည္း မ ကယ္ႏိုင္ဘူး။ အေမရိကန္လည္း မကယ္ႏိုင္ဘူး။ အီးယူလည္း မကယ္ႏိုင္ဘူး။ ဘယ္သူ႔မွ အားမကိုးနဲ႔၊ ကိုယ့္ အားကိုယ္ကိုးၿပီး ကိုယ္ဟာကိုယ္ ေျဖရွင္းၾကလုိ႔ ေရးလုိက္ပါတယ္။
အဲဒီတုန္းကလည္း စာဖတ္ပရိသတ္နဲ႔ လူငယ္ေတြက သေဘာက် ေထာက္ခံၾကပါတယ္။
ဆရာေကာင္း တပည့္ေတြ
အဲဒီတုန္းက “ဆရာေရးတာ သိပ္မွန္တာပဲ” တို႔၊ “ေရးတာ နည္းေတာင္နည္းေသးတယ္” တို႔ ေျပာခဲ့ၾကတဲ့ လူ ငယ္တခ်ဳိ႕ေတာင္ အခုေတာ့ အင္ဂ်ီအို ဆုိင္းဘုတ္ကိုယ္စီနဲ႔ ျဖစ္ေနတာကို ေတြ႔ျမင္ေနရပါတယ္။ ဒါေၾကာင့္ ေရး ရေျပာရျပန္တာပါ။ ဒီလူငယ္ေတြဟာ အစကေတာ့ သန္႔ရွင္းတဲ့ အျဖဴထည္ေတြပါ။ ေနာက္က်မွ ဟိုႏိုင္ငံ ဒီႏိုင္ငံ ေတြမွာ ဟိုသင္တန္း ဒီသင္တန္း ဆုိတာမ်ဳိးေတြ တပတ္ေလာက္၊ ႏွစ္ပတ္ေလာက္ သြားတက္္ခဲ့ၾကၿပီး ျပန္ ေရာက္လာေတာ့ သူတုိ႔ကိုယ္တုိင္ ဆုိင္းဘုတ္ေထာင္ကုန္ၾကေတာ့တာပါပဲ။ တပတ္ႏွစ္ပတ္ သင္တန္းတက္ၿပီး ဘာေတြတတ္လာတယ္ဆုိတာေတာ့ မသိဘူး။ လက္ေတြ႔ျမင္ရတာကေတာ့ သူတို႔ကိုယ္တုိင္ “အင္ဂ်ီအို” ကုန္ ၾကတာပဲျဖစ္တယ္။ မျဖစ္ဘဲေန႐ိုးလား၊ သူတုိ႔ကိုေခၚၿပီး သင္တန္းေပးသူေတြကိုယ္တုိင္က သူတုိ႔ကို ေမ်ာက္အ ျဖစ္ လက္ညႇဳိးထုိးျပၿပီး ဆန္လည္းေတာင္းသူေတြ ျဖစ္ေနၾကတာကိုး။ အတုျမင္ အတတ္သင္ပဲ ေျပာမလား။ “ဆ ရာေကာင္း တပည့္ပဲ” ေျပာမလား မသိေတာ့ပါဘူး။
ဂိုရင္းအဘေရာ့ဒ္
ဆရာေကာင္း တပည့္ေတြ ပန္းေကာင္းပန္ေနၾကတာေတြကေတာ့ မျမင္ခ်င္အဆံုးပါပဲ။ တခ်ဳိ႕က ေအ့ဒ္စ္ဆိုင္း ဘုတ္ ကိုင္ၾကတယ္။ တခ်ဳိ႕က သဘာဝပတ္၀န္းက်င္ထိန္းသိမ္းေရး ဆုိင္းဘုတ္ေထာင္ၾကတယ္။ တခ်ဳိ႕က ေတာ႐ိုင္းတိရစာၦန္ဆုိင္းဘုတ္၊ တခ်ဳိ႕က မိေက်ာင္းထိန္းသိမ္းေရးဆုိင္းဘုတ္၊ တခ်ဳိ႕က ဒီေရေတာဆုိင္းဘုတ္၊ တခ်ဳိ႕က ပလတ္စတစ္ဆုိင္းဘုတ္ စသျဖင့္ ... စသျဖင့္ ဆုိင္းဘုတ္ေတြကေတာ့ စံုသလား မေမးနဲ႔။ အမယ္ ... ဆုိင္းဘုတ္ ဘယ္ေလာက္မ်ားမ်ား အားလံုးပဲ “လန္း” ၾကသဗ်။ “ဝပ္ေရွာ့” ဆုိတာေတြ တက္ဖုိ႔ “ဂိုးရင္းအဘ ေရာ့ဒ္” ဆုိတာေတြလည္း ခဏခဏ ျမင္ေနရ၊ ေတြ႔ေနရ၊ ၾကားေနရသဗ်။ ေနာက္တက္လာတဲ့ ကေလးေတြ ဆက္ၿပီး ဆရာေကာင္းတပည့္ ျဖစ္ကုန္ၾကမွာေတာင္ စိုးရိမ္ရတဲ့ အေျခအေနလုိ႔ေျပာရင္ မလြန္လွဘူးလုိ႔ ထင္ ပါတယ္ခင္ဗ်။
စံျပပုဂိၢဳလ္လုိတယ္
ကေလးေတြအတြက္ ေမတၱာအပို႔ခံၿပီး ဒီလုိ ေရးေနေျပာေနရတာပါ။ အင္ဂ်ီအိုအားလံုး မေကာင္းဘူးလုိ႔ ဆုိတာ မဟုတ္ပါဘူး။ ေစတနာအစစ္၊ ေမတၱာအစစ္၊ က႐ုဏာအစစ္နဲ႔ လုပ္ေနၾကတဲ့ အင္ဂ်ီအုိေတြနဲ႔ ရွင္းသန္႔တဲ့ လူ ငယ္ေတြလည္း ရွိပါတယ္။ ဒါေပမယ့္ အစစ္အမွန္သမားေတြက ေမ်ာက္ျပဆန္ေတာင္းသူေတြလုိ “ေျပ (ျပည္) ေပၚမွာ ေရႊေၾကာ္ျငာထုတ္” တဲ့အလုပ္မ်ဳိးေတြ လုပ္ေလ့မရွိေတာ့ သူတုိ႔အေၾကာင္း ကေလးေတြက မသိၾကဘူး။ ကေလးတုိ႔၊ လူငယ္တို႔ဆုိတာ သူတုိ႔အားက် အတုယူရတဲ့ “စံျပဳပုဂိၢဳလ္” (Role Model) ေတြ ရွိဖုိ႔လုိပါတယ္။ ဒါ ေၾကာင့္ ကြယ္လြန္ရွာၿပီျဖစ္တဲ့ လူ႐ိုးလူေကာင္းႀကီး ျမန္မာ့အလင္း ဦးတင္ အေၾကာင္းကို ႏွစ္ႀကိမ္ သံုးႀကိမ္ ေလာက္ ေရးျပခဲ့ဖူးပါတယ္။ ျမန္မာ့အလင္းသတင္းစာ တုိက္အုပ္ ဦးတင္က ဘုိးဘြားရိပ္သာကို မူလေနရာ ႏွင္း ဆီကုန္းကေန စစ္ၿပီးေတာ့ လက္ရွိေနရာကို ေရႊ႕ေျပာင္းႏိုင္ဖုိ႔ ႀကိဳးစားအားထုတ္ခဲ့သူ ျဖစ္ပါတယ္။ ေရႊ႕ၿပီးတဲ့ ဘုိးဘြားရိပ္သာမွာ မနက္တုိင္း ႐ံုးလာထုိင္ပါတယ္။ ၿပီးမွ ျမန္မာ့အလင္းတုိက္ကို သြားပါတယ္။
ပရဟိတသမားစစ္စစ္
ဦးေလးတင္ ဘုိးဘြားရိပ္သာ ႐ုံးခန္းေရာက္ေတာ့ ဝန္ထမ္းေတြက ေကာ္ဖီတုိ႔၊ မုန္႔တုိ႔ ယူလာၿပီး ဧည့္ခံပါတယ္။ အဲဒီအခါ ဦးေလးတင္က သူ႔ျခင္းထဲ အျမဲပါေနက် ေကာ္ဖီ ဓာတ္ဘူးနဲ႔ ေရေႏြးၾကမ္းဘူးကို ထုတ္ၿပီး “ငါ့မွာ အ ကုန္ပါတယ္။ ဧည့္ခံစရာ မလုိဘူး။ အလွဴရွင္ေတြ လွဴတာက ဘုိးဘြားေတြအတြက္ လွဴတာ၊ တုိ႔အတြက္မပါဘူး။ ဒါေၾကာင့္ ငါလည္း မစားဘူး။ မင္းတုိ႔လည္း မစားၾကနဲ႔” လုိ႔ ဆံုးမပါတယ္။ ဦးေလးတင္ဟာ သူ႔ေကာ္ဖီေလး သူ ထည့္ေသာက္၊ သူ႔ေရေႏြးၾကမ္းေလး သူ ထည့္ေသာက္တာပါ။ ဦးေလးတင္ရဲ႕ စည္းကမ္းတိက်မႈနဲ႔ သမာဓိကို သိတာေၾကာင့္ ဖဆပလအမႈေဆာင္ ေရြးတဲ့အခါမွာ ဗိုလ္ခ်ဳပ္ေအာင္ဆန္းက ႏိုင္ငံေရး ဘယ္တုန္းကမွ မလုပ္ခဲ့ တဲ့ ဦးတင္ကို မရရေအာင္ေခၚၿပီး ေငြကိုင္ရတဲ့ ဘ႑ာေရးမွဴး ခန္႔ခဲ့တာျဖစ္တယ္။ ေနာက္ေတာ့ ဦးႏုက သူ႔ကိုပဲ ဘ႑ာေရးဝန္ႀကီး ခန္႔ပါတယ္။ ေနာက္ဆံုး လႊတ္ေတာ္ဥကၠ႒ တာဝန္ထမ္းေဆာင္ခဲ့ရပါတယ္။ ပရဟိတသမား ဆုိတာ အဲဒီလုိပုဂိၢဳလ္မ်ဳိးကိုမွ ေခၚႏိုင္တာပါ။ ကိုယ္က်ဳိးတစံုတရာ ရယူခံစားၿပီး လုပ္တယ္ဆုိကတည္းက ပရဟိ တသမား မစစ္ေတာ့ပါဘူး။ (အတၱဟိတ+ ပရဟိတ) ႏွစ္ခုေပါင္းၿပီး “အတၱပရဟိတ” သမား “အတၱပရဟိတ လုပ္ငန္း” လုိ႔ပဲ ေခၚသင့္တယ္လုိ႔ ထင္ပါတယ္။ ဘာေၾကာင့္လဲဆုိေတာ့ အတၱဟိတအတြက္ ပရဟိတလုပ္ငန္း လုပ္တာမဟုတ္လား။
လူထုစိန္၀င္း
(Weekly Eleven Journal - September 9 - 2009 ထုတ္မွ ...)
Sunday, September 13, 2009
အတၱပရဟိတလုပ္ငန္း
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Posts
27 comments:
i agree what he said.
ဆရာကိုေလးစားပါတယ္။ေနရာတိုင္းမွာ..........ေဘာင္ထဲမွာ.........အက်ပ္ထဲမွာ.....စိတ္ဓာတ္ေတြ .....
ဦးဝင္းတင္နဲ႔ ဦးစိန္ဝင္း ရွိေနလို႔သာ ေလာကအမွန္တရားကို ၾကားသိေနရတယ္...
ေလာကၾကီးမွာ ထမင္းတလုတ္ကို သိကၡာရွိရွိ စားတတ္ဖို႔ မၾကိဳးစားၾကေတာ႔ဘူးလား.. စဥ္းစားရင္း နဲ႔.... သက္ျပင္းအခါခါခ်မိတယ္..
I understand the author's concerns. Agree there are groups and NGOs who get the fundings and do nothing or do very small things for communities but cheat the funders and community. That is TOTALLY unacceptable.
However, it is too narrow to say and mean that they who want to do for the community cannot get anything from such activities.
There are some religious organizations where you can find people who are volunteering their times without taking any salaries. But it is legal and acceptable to take fair amount of salary to do humanitarian works. What is so wrong with that? Grapes are sour?
I personally want to see a lot of NGO where our youth are taking lead, getting funding by rasing it iside and outside of the coountry, learning how to work for community, learning how to deal with donors. I think which is very very very good. People all around the world are doing it.
I personally would happy to see youth with a lot of sign boards as long as they are taking fair amount of money and contributing to community as they promise in the proposal. Cheaters cannot last long and sincere ones will develop. Is the author encouraging "don;t do anything, just sitting and complainting the situation? what?...
Please do not stop our youth when they are trying to catch up with the development of outside world. This is a kind of platform for youth to share their vision, their concerns and their believes. What is so wrong?
Isn't a reason for us to be proud when we see a group of youth working for say example cyclone victims raising funding from in and out? Hey but do you think you can expect they work for ever as volunteers? Wake up please... The world is changing. The situation are changing in our country as well. Father alone works at the office and all five or six children happily go school and do whatever during thier free time is true in 50 years ago.. Wake up.. Wake up... especaially for a famouse writer it is very important to always awake....
So there are no monkeys in Myanmar?
You are blind if you say there are no monkeys in Myanmar. (you are in line with Junta if your answer is No)
NGOs are changing people in Myanmar into monkeys?
No.Incorrect message. Poeple are in problems not because of NGOs.
If no NGO.Who are doing what for the monkeys? How?
Please advise options. Don't just complaint. Please come with solution.
Actually it is more important to have more NGOs who will watch out the activities of UNs and NGOs, corruptions in these systems and independently report to the world.
I really cannot understand what is the problem with this famous writer. Could someone do interview with him and post it so that we can know more?
What are the problems? I don't see any relationship between the failure of Gamberi and NGOs???
To me, NGOs even though in English words, is from Myanmar culture and context. The way, they operate might have changed based on today situation.
Oh please, please don;t cut people to fit in the clothes. Don;t be too narrow and shallow....
What i realize U Sein Win siad is,
..
Some Bad NGOs are unacceptable ..not every NGOs.
Some Crazy young guys are unacceptable...not every youth.
I think,
nobody should not say U Sein Win as "narrow mind person"
He is great
He is one of great person from Burma.
We must encourage him.
Every person who was born in Burma knows... how dangerous to do like
what he does.
After reading the aritcle from begining to end, I could not find other words than shallow and narrow...
If he really agrees that only some of the NGOs are bad and some are good, why he cannot give example of good NGOs.. and say, why those NGOs cannot do like these NGOs.
And who told him NGOs are for " payahitha" , The concept of NGO is a lot wider than charity. I think people expectations and understanding on NGOs are not correct at the first place.
I have full respect to him as an old person as well as a brilliant writer. But because of his status he has big responsibility. There are a lot of people in our country who will beleive whatever they said without thinking.
Unfortunately or fortunately...sorry I am not one of them and I am ready to say things which I think is correct.So I think you are correct May, when you say nobody should not say he is narrow which means everyone should say he is narrow.
hay friend, innocent...
Thanks for your correct my English.
Of cause...
i am not native English Speaker.
Let me correct what i wrote...
I mean;;
Nobody should say he is narrow mind.
What i wrote mistakenly is..
"nobody should not say U Sein Win as "narrow mind person"
I am sorry for that..
..
..
another things,
you can be ready to say things which I think is correct.,
OK,
I can be ready to say things which I think is correct, too.
Of cause,
I never say any thing that i do not believe.
မသိလို့ ့ ေမးၾကည္ ့ပါ ရ ေစ
NGOs ရဲ ့ အလုပ္က
ပရဟိတ မဟုတ္ ရ င္ ဘာ လဲ
ၿပီးေတာ့
ပရဟိတ ဆို တာ ဘာ လဲ
သိတဲ့သူ ေၿပာၿပၾကည့္ပါလား
တကယ္တတ္သိတဲ့ သူမွ ေနာ္
NGOs ဟာ ပရဟိတ ဟုတ္မဟုတ္ေတာ့ မသိပါဘူး
ဒါေပမယ့္ NGOs မွာ လုပ္သူမ်ားဟာ
ပရဟိတစိတ္ ရွိရပါမယ္
NGOs နဲ့ ့ humanitarian က ေတာ္ေတာ္ အမ်ိဴးေတာ္ၾကတာဆိုဘဲ
ပရဟိတစိတ္ မရွိဘဲ နဲ ့ NGOs မွာမလုပ္ၾကပါနဲ ့
ဒါမွ မဟုတ္လို ့ကေတာ့ ,
ပရဟိတစိတ္မရွိတဲ့ ၀န္ထမ္းမ်ားေၾကာင့္
NGOs လည္း က်က္သေရ ယုတ္ေလ်ာ့ရပါတယ္
To in no cent
You sir are a bonehead who thought himself as a smart-ass.
The concept of Non-governmental organization is totally depends on what their chosen field is.
But in Burma,most NGOs are educational,developmental,environmental and welfare oriented.
Under their respective titles, they are operating according to guidelines of their parent units which are mostly from Western countries.Again, there is no problem with westerners and their organizations,but are problems with the people who are our Burmese.
You try to belittle U Sein Win by your words from lamebrain. You thought writing English and speaking English fairly means someone is so smart such as yourself...Humm..!!
Well, sir my employees are Americans and most of them are Rednecks and boneheads,living on paycheck to paycheck basic,but not surprisingly their writing and speaking skill is way better than yours.
So, don't be so arrogant and do pause your thinking as a burst bubble in the air,likewise disregard yourself such a wonderful person but as the idiot of all time
Yup...! big fat idiot....
The writer has no authority over NGOs, what kind of writer can selectively give out names of bad NGOs and good ones?
It is,indeed, ethical issue.
As a respectful writer,his duty is not to blame one individual organization, but to point out what really is going on in that business, and to correct young and curious minds.
ေဟ့ေကာင္ေရ...
မင္းကိုမင္းသိပ္ျပီး ေတာ္လွျပီ ေတြးနိုင္လွျပီ ထင္ျပီး လူတကာကိုလုိက္ျပီး စိတ္ခ်ဥ္ေပါက္တိုင္း မင္း ေျမာက္ၾကြေျမာက္ၾကြနဲ ့လိုက္ျပီး ေျပာခ်င္တိုင္း ငါ့စကားႏြားရ မေစာ္ကားနဲ႔ကြ ။
မင္း ဖက္မွာ ပိုျပီး ျပည့္စံုတ ဲ့တင္ျပမွဳရွိရင္ တင္လိုက္ အားလံုး အက်ိဳးရွိေအာင္ ။
အဲလိုမဟုတ္လို ့ကေတာ့ နိုင္ငံျခားတိုင္းျပည္မွာေန၊ လူတကာကို ကိုယ့္ တပည့္ေလာက္ထင္တဲ့စိတ္န ဲ့ ၀င္၀င္ျပီး လူလည္စကားေတြေျပာ ၊ ျမန္မာနိုင္ငံသားတေယာက္ျဖစ္ျပီး ျမန္မာလိုေတာင္ မေရးခ်င္တာလား မေရးနိုင္တာလား မသိ၊ မင္းလိုေကာင္မွာ တကယ္တန္းတိုင္းျပည္န ဲ့လူမိ်ဳးအေပၚမွာ တိုးတက္ေစခ်င္တ ဲ့ေစတနာအမွန္တကယ္ရွိရင္ ဦးစိန္၀င္းကို လာအျပစ္တင္ျပီး တလြဲေျပာဖို ့မရွိဘူး။ အဲဒီ ဦးစိန္၀င္းတင္ျပမွဳအားနည္းေနရင္ လိုေနရင္ မင္း က ျဖည့္ေပးတဲ့ တျခားရွုေထာင့္က ေတြးေခၚျပီး ပံ့ပိုးတ ဲ့ အျမင္န ဲ့ေရးျပမယ္ဆိုရင္ စာဖတ္သူေတြအတြက္ေရာ လူငယ္ေတြန ဲ့အနာဂါတ္မိ်ဳးဆက္အတြက္ေရာ သိပ္ေကာင္းမယ့္ကိစၥျဖစ္တယ္ကြ။
တခုေတာ့ ေျပာလိုက္မယ္ ။
မင္းလိုေကာင္စား အမ်ားသား လား လကြ ။
To None,
Sorry I did not get your point. What are you talking about? What are your intensions? To tell other people how many employees you have or what? I don’t care and am not interested how many employees (American) or (from other planet) you have. Don’t compare me with you and don’t ever think everyone has same mentality like you do to be proud to have good English. English is just a language. What is so special about it? I am here not for English writing skills competition. I am not a native English speaker so it is obvious Americans have better English skills than I have. Nothing is wrong. Nothing to be proud or nothing to be shame. If I have written some mistakes, tell me so that I can correct.
I am here just presenting my thoughts on the article which obviously narrow and shallow. Guys, having a lot of NGOs is a good signs for any developing country. The author generalizes all the NGOs are equally bad although he has a sentence he does not mean all are bad to buffer but it was obvious he hates all the NGOs and cannot appreciate which are good and which are bad. It is shown in his following sentences.
And finally, None… Who told you there is nobody like me? You are so emotional and cannot see things clearly. That’s is funny and I do not know how you are managing with a lot of American employees who are born in American, speak and write perfect English and work under your supervision and getting your salary.
I read the article with clear mind. I don’t care who wrote it. I focus on the contents and it is narrow and shallow to me. That’s it. Why we have to take all the things just because of someone say. There are a lot of great people who are respectful but it does not mean we do not need to use our brain. Sorry. It is not being proud, it is trying to see things clearly. And trying to express thought clearly. It is not trying to say I am “the” only person. But I do hope youth have that courage and freedom to think and express their opinion freely. Don’t ever try to stop it by showing of your status, your old age, with your employees or your wife whatever...Anyway, it won’t work with me…Next time, please write down the list of your American employees….. And I thank you for your rude words. Use more so that I can borrow them from you in future communications. (If I am still want to).. At least, you made my day.. Funny…
no problem with westerners and their organizations,but are problems with the people who are our Burmese..
One more question. Why no problems with people from West but with Burmese?
Thank twice what you mean by this sentence?
Do you have double standard? Oh yes, American guy can do, Oh No, Burmese guy cannot do?.. Or what? What? Wake up? Wake up? Open your heart... let bad things flow out...
To In no cent...
Did you really get what message author wanted to give ?
Again... do try writing Burmese language.
ကိုယ့္ဆရာရယ္ ေဒါသခ်ည္ပါပဲလား။
ဆရာ ဦးစိန္၀င္း ေရးတဲ့ စာကို ေရာ ေသခ်ာ (ျမန္မာစာ)နားလည္ရဲ့လား ။ သူေပးခ်င္တဲ့ အခ်က္အလက္ကိုေရာ ရရဲ့လား ။
မင္းက ျမန္မာလိုေရးရမွာ၀န္ေလးလို ့လား
ဒါမွမဟုတ္ျမန္မာလိုပဲ မတတ္လို ့လား မင္းေရးေနတာေတြက အကုန္ ဘိုလိုပဲလိုေတြခ်ည္မို႔ ေျပာတာေပါ့ကြာ။ ဒါေၾကာင့္လဲ မင့္ကို ဘိလပ္လိုျပန္ျပီးေရး လိုက္ရတာပါ ပထမ အပိုဒ္ေတြမွာ..။
ခုေခတ္ၾကီးထဲမွာ ေလာကဓါတ္ပညာေလး နည္းနည္းတတ္ျပီး ဘိလပ္လို မွဳတ္တတ္ ျခစ္တတ္ရင္ ပဲ ကိုယ့္ကိုယ္ကိုယ္ စၾကၤ၀ေတးေလာက္ထင္ေနတဲ့ေကာင္ေတြတပံုၾကီးကြ။
အဲဒီေကာင္ေတြပဲ တတိယ အုပ္စုေတြ ဘာေလ့လာသူ ညာေလ့လာသူေတြလုပ္ျပီး ျပည္သူလူထုကို ဆရာၾကီးေတြလုပ္ နအဖ ကိုပဲ ဒူးေျပးဖက္ေတာ့မလိုလို သူတို ့ကိုယ္သူတို ့န ဲ့သူတို ့ရဲ့အေတြးအေခၚေတြကပဲ အနာဂါတ္တိုင္းျပည္အတြက္ အဓိက က်သလိုလို သူတိ ု့ေျပာသလို မလုပ္ရင္ပဲ သမုိင္းေၾကာင္းတခုလံုး ေရစုန္ေမ်ာ ေတာ့မလိုလို အေပါက္ေတြန ဲ့ေကာင္ေတြဟာ အျမဲ ပါးစပ္က ဘိလပ္လိုေတြ ရႊတ္ရွက္ဒြတ္ဒက္ေတြန ဲ့ လူေတြၾကားထဲ လူေတြအထင္ၾကီးမလားဆိုျပီး မိခင္ ဘာသာစကားကိုတတ္လွ်က္ ဘိလပ္လိုမွသိပ္အာေတြ ့ေနတဲ့ေကာင္ေတြတပံုၾကီးကြ။
ကိုရင့္ၾကည့္ရတာလဲ ျမန္မာနိုင္ငံသားေတြ ျမန္မာလို ဖတ္ခ်င္လို့ လာလာဖတ္ေနတ ဲ့ဘေလာ့မွာ လည္ပင္းေၾကာင္လွ်ာသီးၾကီးပတ္ ပတ္ျပီး သကၠလတ္ ကုတ္အက်ၤ ီၾကီး ေႏြေခါင္ေခါင္၀တ္လုိ ့ ရွမ္းေဘာင္းဘီ ကို ခါးပါတ္ကြင္းတပ္ ၊ ႏြားလည္ပတ္ၾကိဳးထည့္ပတ္ျပီး ရြာလည္ေခါင္ ဖုန္တေထာငး္ေထာင္းမွာ အိုင္ ဆီး အိုင္ဆီးလုပ္ေနတဲ့ ကိုလိုနီေခတ္ဘိုရူးန ဲ့ တူေနလြန္းလို ့လကြဲ ့..။
အင္မတန္မွ လူငယ္ေတြ ဖတ္သင့္ နမူနာယူသင့္တဲ့ လူ ့ယဥ္ေက်းၾကီးတစ္ေယာက္အေၾကာင္းကို ပါ ဆရာၾကီး ဦးစိန္၀င္းက လူငယ္ေတြအတြက္ စံျပ ပုဂၢိဳလ္တစ္ေယာက္အေနန ဲ့ေတာင္ မီးေမာင္းထိုးျပခဲ့ေသးတယ္။
မင္း အင္မတန္မွ ဆရာလုပ္ခ်င္စိတ္ရွိျပီး ေတာ္ေတာ္လဲ ျမန္မာစာကို ရွင္းရွင္းလင္းလင္း မဖတ္တတ္ေသးဘူးပဲကြယ့္ ။
ဆရာၾကီးေျပာသြားတဲ့အထဲမွာ အဲဒီ အဖြဲ ့အစည္းေတြကိုမလိုလားတာ ရယ္လို ့မပါဘူး။
မလိုလားဖြယ္ျဖစ္ရပ္ေတြကို ပဲ ဟန္ ့တာ ျဖစ္တယ္။
အဲဒါကိုလဲ ေသခ်ာ ျမင္သာလွ်က္နဲ ့တမင္မျမင္တာပဲလား ေမာင္ရင္ရယ္..။
ေအး အေနာက္နိုင္ငံသားေတြကိစၥျပသနာမရွိဘူးလို ့ေျပာခဲ့တာက အေနာက္နိုင္ငံသားေတြက သူတို ့ကိစၥနဲ ့သူတို ့တိုင္းျပည္မွာပဲျဖစ္တဲ့အရာေတြကို ဆိုလိုတာျဖစ္တယ္။ တို ့တိုင္းျပည္ကို အေနာက္နိုင္ငံသား ၊ အေရွ ့နိုင္ငံသား ဘာနိုင္ငံသားကမွ ၀င္လာျပီး စီးစီးပိုးပိုးနဲ ့ သူတို ့ေပးမွေကြ်းမွစားရတဲ့လူေတြဆိုတဲ့အျမင္နဲ ့ တို ့လူမိ်ဳးေတြကို ၾကည့္တာ အထင္ေသးတာေတာ့ မခံနိုင္ဘူးကြ။ အဲသလိုပဲ ခု ေခတ္ အဲဒီ အဖြဲ ့အစည္းေတြမွာ ဆိုင္းဘုတ္ေထာင္ျပီး ေယာင္ျပ ဖုန္ထေနတဲ့ေကာင္ေတြဟာ ျမန္မာျပည္သားျမန္မာနိုင္ငံသား ျမန္မာ လူမိ်ဳးေတြျဖစ္တယ္ကြ အဲဒီေကာင္ေတြက ဘာနဲ ့တူသလဲ ဆိုေတာ့ ကိုလိုနီေခတ္စကားျပန္ လုပ္ေပါက္ေတြနဲ ့ တေက်ာ့ျပန္ အလိုေတာ္ရိပံုစံေတြျဖစ္ေနတာေတြ ခ်စ္တီးစကားျပန္ ပံုေပါက္ေနတာေတြ ကိုလဲ ျမင္ေနၾကားေနရတယ္ကြ။
ဒီေတာ့ ဆရာၾကီး ေျပာတာ ေရးတာ ဟာ မမွားသလို ဆရာၾကီးက က်ဥ္းေျမာင္းသူမဟုတ္ဘူး။
ေနာက္တခါ ထပ္ေျပာခဲ့မယ္ ေမာင္ အင္ နိုး ဆန္ ့
မင္းျမန္မာလို မေဆြးေႏြးသမွ်ေတာ့ ျပန္ျပီး မင္းကို လက္ေညာင္းခံျပီးေဆြးေႏြးေတာ့မယ္မဟုတ္သလို ေဆြးေႏြးရေလာက္တ ဲ့ ပုဂၢိဳလ္လဲ မဟုတ္ဘူး အရက္၀ိုင္းပဲေလွာ္နွိုက္ ၊ ဖဲ၀ိုင္း မုန္ ့ဖိုးေတာင္းတဲ့ ခပ္ခ်ာခ်ာ လို ့ပဲ သေဘာထားျပီး ဥေပကၡာျပဳေနေတာ့မယ္ ဟုတ္ပလား ။
က်မ္းမာပါေစ
waiting for the response of so called "innocent".
Hello, Mr. Shallow Narrow,
What is so important about language? I can read, write and speak Burmese very well, but it takes longer time to type in Burmese for me. I can communicate in English but obviously not like a native speaker. What’s wrong? I know my strengths and weaknesses. I decided what is good for me in different situations. I cannot spend too much time on typing. I have no intension to show off among Burmese youth (like you probably do) so I just expressed my thought in whatever way I am comfortable. There is no such a rule people cannot write comments in English. So what is so wrong?
You can wear whatever you like as long as it is decent. Actually it is you who is so funny. Try to sound like a real old Burmese man using “Maung Yin” and so which nobody today use in day to day communication. That alone clearly proves that you are one of those who are just superficial Burmese wearing Tite Phone and Pa Sone for show but inside has mentality always ready to worship Westerners.
Don’t discuss anymore. You have showed your stupidity, you have showed your shallow and narrow mind, you have boasted that you have American employees (frankly I don’t believe it at all..hahaha maybe you might have one or two American Colleagues you know I am laughing), you have showed off your ability to write English, you have beautifully showed your ability to type in Burmese. You have showed how rude you are. There is nothing left for you to discuss. I am not responding to your comments wasting my time even though you change your user name and try to have shadow remarks using different names.
Hay man,
You should not call some one 'shallow or narrow '
See,
..
Who is rude now ?
English is nothing but just a language and a tool. I just took few months to study this language, I made a lot of mistakes at the beginning and now I have improved a lot. Everyone can learn it. If you find difficulties to read, read more. If you find difficulties to write, write more. I practiced a lot and I can write as following story in less than five minutes. I am glad about it. But there is no reason to be proud about it. Mistakes? Definitely there will be many.. as long as people can understand I think it is fine. We can always read two times, three times to correct them. Everyone can do. Please try, we need this language not to be bullied by others.
Once upon a time, there was a woman who unfortunately had to sleep with different men for her living. It was disturbing for the people in her quarter but they tolerated her and were able to live in peace most of the time. But the problem was with the woman. She felt very sorry about her way of living, she thought people looked down on her and she felt inferior whenever she saw people leading decent lives honestly.
So she used to make problems, felt offended when she heard other people talking about decent things, knew about other people “innocent” ambitions and saw other people making their lives in proper way. Then she chose the target. How did she make problems with them?
She would dressed in her best clothes, wore cheap jewels she still had and borrowed some more from her customers, stood at the corner of the road and shouted to those people using all the unpleasant languages she learnt from her living. She would say what do you think of yourself? What you think of me? My father was xxxx. My grand father was xxxx. My customers were from America and they paid me USD so I was earning dollars..etc. Since she was just a prostitute she did not know which words were to be proud which were to be shamed. So she would sometimes made remarks like, do you think you a nice woman and proud of having a husband. Hum!! I sleep 20 men in a night. It was annoying and funny for the people in the quarter. The worst thing was sometimes, she would offer free sex to the gangsters and ask them to harass people she hated. But she was embarrassed for what she did when she cooled down again because she still had some power to think logically. Some people are even worse than that woman.
ဟင္း......... ေနာက္ဆံုးေတာ႔လဲၿငင္းက် တာပါပဲ
ဟင္း......... ေနာက္ဆံုးေတာ႔လဲၿငင္းက် တာပါပဲ
ဟင္း......... ေနာက္ဆံုးေတာ႔လဲၿငင္းက် တာပါပဲ
It is not arguing about the content Tae Tae. The content is clear and no need Burmese to Burmese translation. Everyone can read. Just need clear and open mind.
It is all about how I wrote English (seems that person might have thought people from Myanmar cannot read and write English like him who is worshipping English) and he/she tried to read my mind comparing with his or her own mentality. Tried to have an argument using big words and fake stories to see how other party will feel. When he/she realized the only thing he/she good at is typing in Burmese, he/she tried to change the game rules. Nobody buy his/her idea, keep quiet and find other place to bark.
Actually, I can tell you.there are such kind of people, they did all wrong things by themselves, but in front of people, pretend and talk like a noble person. Follow that person and you will know what he/she has done. You will be surprised to know a lot of concerns the Author mentioned in his articles has done by such person. But they will still say in front of people “ Ba Ba is right. At the back? Who knows maybe he is cursing.
I have only few minute left. In Burmese we can write very briefly like that.
တိုက္ပံုတကားတကား ဝတ္၊ ဟိုေယာင္ဒီေယာင္၊ ဟိုေဟာင္ဒီေဟာင္၊ ရသမွ်အခြင့္အေရးယူ၊မဟန္ျပန္ေျပး၊ မေအxx.ေခြးပါးစပ္နတ္စကားထြက္၊
If I have few more minutes, I can write a poem. Maybe one day.
Innocent
* Age: 21
* Astrological Sign: Capricorn
* Zodiac Year: Rabbit
* Industry: Tourism
* Occupation: Porn Star
* Location: Yangon : Myanmar (Burma)
Hey Porn Star,
Cut your bullshit! Your comments are out of topic and seems like you're the only one who's worshipping English. Damn man... you're so narrow minded that you can't even understand what the writers, Syar Lu Htu Sein Win, None N thae thae said. You should be ashame of yourself that although you understand what they said looks like you're ignoring their fact and just posting your nonsense comments. Change your name to "The narrow minded Porn Star, NonSense"!
Last but not least, just wanna say what None said "မင္း ဖက္မွာ ပိုျပီး ျပည့္စံုတဲ့တင္ျပမွဳရွိရင္ တင္လိုက္ အားလံုး အက်ိဳးရွိေအာင္ ။" , if not you're just wasting everybody's time. I'll also not response to every nonsense comment.
Innocent
* Age: 21
* Astrological Sign: Capricorn
* Zodiac Year: Rabbit
* Industry: Tourism
* Occupation: Porn Star
* Location: Yangon : Myanmar (Burma)
Hey Porn Star,
Cut your bullshit! Your comments are out of topic and seems like you're the only one who's worshipping English. Damn man... you're so narrow minded that you can't even understand what the writers, Syar Lu Htu Sein Win, None N thae thae said. You should be ashame of yourself that although you understand what they said looks like you're ignoring their fact and just posting your nonsense comments. Change your name to "The narrow minded Porn Star, NonSense"!
Last but not least, just wanna say what None said "မင္း ဖက္မွာ ပိုျပီး ျပည့္စံုတဲ့တင္ျပမွဳရွိရင္ တင္လိုက္ အားလံုး အက်ိဳးရွိေအာင္ ။" , if not you're just wasting everybody's time. I'll also not response to every nonsense comment.
Hahahahahaha!!!
Hahahahahahaha!
Whaa hahahahhaaaaa!!!
Mother- Daw Pu
Father-Tom Rude
Son-John Rude Pu
Guess what he/she worshit...
None (a) John (half Myanmar, Half Bo), I am not going read your stupid comments here anymore. Write whatever you write and continue showing your stupidity...
After all it is so funny Nohn, next time try to vote yourself....hahahahahaha, whahahahaha
Post a Comment